Serious stuff, if confirmed! I have some serious doubts about this claim! My hunch is we are dealing here with junk journalism and junk science.
The study was reportedly commissioned by the NGO Pesticide Action Network?
Notice these poisoning numbers are based on estimates (extrapolation?) not hard data! From about 370,000 actually reported cases, they come up with over 400 million cases estimate! This is a serious jump!
Notice they refer to farmers, but the hard data appears to be all people not just farmers! The abstract of the research article does not mention how many farmers were actually poisoned!
Notice also the use of "non fetal" in this context! How serious were these poisonings?
Notice the research article is primarily a meta study of research articles.
"... with southern Asia, southeast Asia, and East Africa most affected, finds a study published yesterday in Frontiers in Public Health, which also estimated 11,000 annual deaths from pesticide poisoning; the authors say immediate action is required to reduce pesticide use, which doubled from 1990 to 2023. ..."
"... The overall highest national incidence of poisoning was in Burkina Faso in west Africa, where nearly 84% of farmers and farm workers were reported to have experienced poisoning. ..."
From the abstract:
"Background:
Human poisoning by pesticides has long been seen as a severe public health problem.
As early as 1990, a task force of the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that about one million unintentional pesticide poisonings occur annually, leading to approximately 20,000 deaths.
In 2020, a systematic review found that about 385 million cases of unintentional, acute pesticide poisoning (UAPP) were occurring every year.
Our aim is to update the annual global estimate of UAPP, based on a systematic review of available data.
Methods:
We updated the existing systematic review of the scientific literature to include the period from 2006 to 2023 supplemented by mortality data from WHO.
We extracted data from publications and the WHO Mortality Database, then performed country-wise synopses, and arrived at annual numbers of national UAPP. World-wide UAPP was estimated based on national figures and population data for worldwide regions. We conducted a sensitivity analysis to illustrate the effects of different study designs on the global estimate.
Results:
In total 139 countries were covered, including 62 countries covered by 214 articles from 2006 to 2023, and an additional 77 countries covered by data from the WHO Mortality Database.
Approximately 369,632 annual cases of UAPP were reported by the extracted publications, resulting from 9,182 fatalities and 360,450 non-fatal cases.
On this basis, we estimate that about 402 to 433 million cases of UAPP occur annually worldwide, including around 11,000 fatalities.
Based on a worldwide farming population of approximately 934 million, this means that an estimated 46% of farmers are being poisoned by pesticides every year.
The greatest estimated number of non-fatal UAPP cases is in southern Asia, followed by south-eastern Asia and east Africa.
Conclusion:
Along with other estimates, robust evidence is presented that acute pesticide poisoning is an ongoing major global public health challenge.
There is an urgent need to recognize the high burden of non-fatal UAPP, particularly on farmers and farmworkers. The implementation of the recommendation by the Council of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), to phase out highly hazardous pesticides (HHPs) could significantly reduce the burden of UAPP."
Almost half of world’s farmers poisoned by pesticides every year, experts find "Study reveals that pesticide poisoning kills 11,000 people each year, with India accounting for nearly 60% of fatalities"
Worldwide unintentional acute pesticide poisonings: reassessing the occupational and non-occupational burden (open access)
Notice that French language articles were not included and medical/clinical outcomes of these poisonings.
Fig. 2 Number (x 1,000) of non-fatal untentional pesticide poisonings in UN Regions (total = 433 million).
No comments:
Post a Comment