Monday, June 19, 2023

How existential risk became the biggest meme in AI thanks to two Turing Award winners

Very recommendable! The alarmism and hysteria recently raised by two leading AI researchers, i.e. Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, was irresponsible!

"Yann LeCun, a Turing Award winner, ... why he thinks the idea that a superintelligent AI system will take over the world is “preposterously ridiculous.” 

People are worried about AI systems that “are going to be able to recruit all the resources in the world to transform the universe into paper clips,” LeCun said. “That’s just insane.” (He was referring to the “paper clip maximizer problem,” a thought experiment in which an AI asked to make as many paper clips as possible does so in ways that ultimately harms humans, while still fulfilling its main objective.) 

He is in stark opposition to Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, two pioneering AI researchers (and the two other “godfathers of AI”), who shared the Turing prize with LeCun. Both have recently become outspoken about  existential AI risk.

Joelle Pineau, Meta’s vice president of AI research, agrees with LeCun. She calls the conversation ”unhinged.” The extreme focus on future risks does not leave much bandwidth to talk about current AI harms, she says. ...  [The existential-risk crowd] have essentially put an infinite cost on that outcome,” says Pineau. 

“When you put an infinite cost, you can’t have any rational discussions about any other outcomes. And that takes the oxygen out of the room for any other discussion, which I think is too bad.”

While talking about existential risk is a signal that tech people are aware of AI risks, tech doomers have a bigger ulterior motive, LeCun and Pineau say: influencing the laws that govern tech. ..."

How existential risk became the biggest meme in AI

No comments: